Heart-Shaped Whoopie Pies…plus a Wilton Valentine’s Giveaway!

I can already hear the creak of the step stool hinge unfolding the second I tell my 4-year old daughter that I’m about to bake something that involves sprinkles. That’s her cue to drop what she’s doing and get herself propped up next to me at the kitchen island to get involved in the action.

This weekend Heart-Shaped Whoopie Pies were on the menu. We had so much fun with the Bunny Whoopie Pies we made last year at Easter that I was eager to try some for Valentine’s Day. If you’ve never tasted a whoopie pie, these pillowy cakes with marshmallow frosting sandwiched in between are a real treat. Once again, we turned to a Wilton pan (included in today’s giveaway!) to create the fun shape. We decorated them simply with Valentine’s sprinkles around the edges but you can also get really creative and pipe words and other designs on top (like these from Baking Bites).

Ready to bake some fun Valentine’s treats of your own? Wilton is sponsoring a fabulous giveaway for us today: a Valentine’s Day Baking Prize Pack, valued at $50, including the heart-shaped whoopie pie pan plus Valentine’s Day cookie cutters, a pie press, sprinkles and more. Read on for how to enter the giveaway plus the Heart-Shaped Whoopie Pies recipe! [THE GIVEAWAY IS NOW CLOSED]

Valentine's Day Baking Prize Pack from Wilton

Win a Valentine’s Day Baking Prize Pack from Wilton, including:

  • Wilton Heart-Shaped Whoopie Pie Pan
  • Micro Hearts Sprinkles
  • Jumbo Hearts Sprinkles
  • You Bake Me Smile Window Bag
  • Text Message Icing Decs
  • Heart Shaped Mini Pie Press
  • Hearts a Flutter Cookie Cutter Set
  • You Bake Me Smile Combo Cupcake (baking cups & picks)
  • Valentine’s Nonpareils

Here are five ways to enter, you can do any or all of them (please leave separate comments for each entry): [THE GIVEAWAY IS NOW CLOSED]

The giveaway will close on Wednesday, February 8 at noon PST. I will use random.org to select one winner and I will announce the winner in this post. I will contact the winner via e-mail – if I don’t receive a response within 5 days I will draw another name. My apologies to international readers, the prize can only be shipped to U.S. addresses.

** UPDATE 2/8/12: Congratulations to our winner, #69 Kathryn! **

Heart-Shaped Whoopie Pies

Many thanks to Wilton for sponsoring today’s giveaway.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  1. I follow you on twitter!

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  2. I follow you on Pinterest too! 🙂

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  3. Michelle wrote:

    I am looking forward to making a strawberry cheesecake.

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  4. Michelle wrote:

    I already subscribe to your blog via email.

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  5. Michelle wrote:

    I already like your facebook page

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  6. Rosemary wrote:

    I would make heart shaped whoopie pies too! 🙂
    And I liked you on facebook!

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  7. T.R. wrote:

    What V-Day treats and I thinking of making fudge brownies. I love brownies and they are just a great comfort/love food. Though I wouldn’t mind making these whoopie pies.

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  8. Debby G. wrote:

    A giant heart shaped cookie!

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  9. Debby G. wrote:

    I subscribe to your RSS feed.

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  10. Armindy wrote:

    Wow! These look delicious. I’ll have to try and make these Valentines’ Day this year if I can. A friend of mine has a birthday the day before Valentines’ and I’m making him a car cake- my first 3D cake without help from a pan. Yikes. Then I have been ordered by my mom to make her some truffles. Maybe I’ll just sneak her some Whoopie Pies instead. ;D
    Ah, I’m now following you on Pinterest. 🙂

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  11. Theresa wrote:

    Honestly I was thinking of just buying some chocolate covered strawberries for my husband. They’re not my thing but he really loves them. Maybe I shouldn’t wimp out and at least dip them myself? We’ll see 🙂

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  12. Angela wrote:

    What a cute idea! I planned to make cookies to share at work, but these look a bit more fun!

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  13. JessFee wrote:

    So like I have posted before I was going to look around on your blog and it was a treat to see your corn muffin recipe. I had everything on hand to make them. I was making chili anyways so the corn muffins where a add on and a hit with my boyfriend and I. <3 I am so happy to of found your blog.. from your new fan.. Jess 🙂

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  14. Jessica F wrote:

    I’m hoping to make cake pops this year!

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  15. Jessica F wrote:

    I like Cooking on the Side on facebook 🙂

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  16. Jessica F wrote:

    following you on twitter!

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  17. Kathryn wrote:

    I’ll be making oreo cheesecake truffles.

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  18. Kathryn wrote:

    I follow you on Pinterest

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  19. Kathryn wrote:

    And I follow you on Twitter

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  20. Ann wrote:

    I plan on making these tiny ladybugs again (lovebugs! http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=562407274376&set=a.519946840426.2027892.22501825&type=3&theater ) for Valentine’s, among other cut-out cookies!

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  21. Victoria Schwartz wrote:

    I’m thinking of making a heart-shaped meringue and filling it with raspberries. I’ll probably make some chocolate meringue cookies while I’m at it.

    Posted 2.7.12 Reply
  22. Carolyn wrote:

    Those whoopie pies look wonderful! This year for my daughter’s class, we’re going to make things easy on ourselves and make chocolate chip cookies with a twist. We bought some cherry flavoured M&Ms to put in them too!

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
    • I haven’t seen cherry M&Ms yet – how cool, I need to find those!

      Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  23. Carolyn wrote:

    Like you FB…I thought I already did, but apparently not!

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  24. I can’t wait to make boston cream pie cupcakes for my sweetheart!

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  25. I follow you on Twitter! @juanitascocina

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  26. Following you on Pinterest! (Jen N Linda)

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  27. Liked Cooking on the Side on FB! (juanitascocina)

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  28. Subscribed by RSS feed to your site!

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  29. Amy in Austin wrote:

    I’m hoping to make graham crackers and heart-shaped shortbread. Maybe even chocolate dipped.

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  30. Amy in Austin wrote:

    I followed you on Pinterest.

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  31. Amy in Austin wrote:

    I ‘liked’ you on Facebook

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  32. Mary wrote:

    I’ll be making Star Wars shaped chocolates for my bf for Valentine’s Day this year!

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  33. Mary wrote:

    I follow you on Twitter!

    Posted 2.8.12 Reply
  34. Marilyn wrote:

    Thank you for posting these instructions and recipes!!! I have a Wilton Heart-Shaped Whoopie Pie pan that came with no paper work. Now, thx to you, I can make Whoopie Pies for today==Valentines Day! I am going to try making the cake part from a cake mix and then make the filling recipe…wish me luck!! I’m making them for dinner tonight for my Mom and Hubby. Hubby is making Surf & Turf for dinner…I thought this would be the perfect dessert!

    Have a love-filled, fun-filled Valentines Day!


    Posted 2.14.12 Reply
  35. Wendy Marstaller wrote:

    I made these last Sunday, the cakes were way to big so I cut down the amount of dough and that worked better, smoothing them out with a knife before baking also helped. The frosting was like soup and I have made a lot of Whoopie pies in the past. I followed the recipe and even my husband said, “what happened to the filling?” The cake tasted fine but the filling was not good at all.

    Posted 2.8.13 Reply
    • Hi Wendy,

      Sorry to hear the filling didn’t work out for you. I hope you didn’t maybe leave out an ingredient? Or perhaps melt the butter rather than soften it? Between the marshmallow cream, sugar and solid-state butter it would be pretty hard for it to turn out like soup – there’s nothing liquid in it but a small amount of vanilla. It sounds like something didn’t go quite right. Glad the cakes tasted good!

      ~ Kathy

      Posted 2.8.13 Reply